This post started as a reply to a comment on another thread, but I wanted to share it here in case it helps anyone else facing the same challenge.
So what do you do when you’ve got four solid outlines, a head full of excitement, and a well-earned writing break (for the sake of your sanity and your partner’s)? And you’re asking yourself: Which one has the most potential? Which one do I pour myself into next?
Having too many ideas is a blessing—but it can also be overwhelming. Creative overload can feel just as paralyzing as writer’s block. So how do you choose your next best project?
Here are a few strategies that might help you focus, commit, and move forward with confidence:
(insert your original list of suggestions here, starting with “Go With Your Gut”)
1. Go With Your Gut
Which idea won’t leave you alone? The one that shows up when you’re trying to sleep or takes over your shower thoughts? That’s the idea that’s already living rent-free in your brain. It’s got roots—and passion matters more than polish when you’re about to dive into a full draft.
2. Pitch It (Even Just to Yourself)
Boil each outline down to a one- or two-sentence pitch. Say it out loud. Which one feels punchy? Which one makes you go “oooh”? Bonus points if you share it with a trusted writing buddy or your partner and they lean in, curious. That spark of interest matters.
3. Imagine the Long Haul
Ask yourself: if I had to spend the next year with this story—writing it, revising it, talking about it, marketing it—would I still love it six months from now? Some ideas are fun flings. Others are long-term material. Figure out which one you want to marry.
4. Check the Timing
Is one of your stories especially timely right now? Maybe it touches on themes that are trending or fills a gap in your current genre. This doesn’t mean chasing fads, but if one of your ideas happens to line up with what readers are hungry for, it might be worth giving it a shot now instead of later.
5. Test-Drive Each One
This one’s for my fellow pantsers: pick a random scene from each outline—NOT the beginning—and write it. Just 500 to 1,000 words. No pressure, no edits. See which one comes to life on the page. That natural flow is a sign of creative compatibility.
6. Let Your Subconscious Work
If you’re in that 3-month break phase, take advantage of it. Let your ideas simmer. Revisit each outline occasionally without committing. Journal about your characters. Make playlists or aesthetic boards. Sometimes the best choice becomes clear when you’re not actively forcing it.
7. Pick One and Go All In
At the end of the day, the best story isn’t just the one with the most “potential”—it’s the one you actually write. You don’t need to wait for the perfect moment or the perfect idea. Pick the one that calls to you the loudest, silence the rest for now, and dive in.
You can always come back to the others later—and you’ll probably be an even better writer when you do.
Bonus: Resources to Help You Decide
If you’re still feeling stuck, here are a few tools that might help you untangle the idea web:
- 🧠 Notion or Trello – Create a “Story Ideas” board and rate each idea based on passion, genre fit, and marketability.
- 📚 Save the Cat! Writes a Novel – Use the beat sheet framework to see which idea holds the strongest structure.
- ✍️ Story Idea Scorecard (create your own or grab a template) – Rank each idea on categories like emotional connection, uniqueness, genre expectations, and personal excitement.
- 🗂️ Scrivener or Plottr – Great for organizing outlines visually and spotting which project has the most depth.
- 🎧 Writing Podcasts – Episodes from Writing Excuses, The Creative Penn, or The Shit No One Tells You About Writing often dive into the idea-to-draft journey.
- ✨ Tarot or Oracle Cards (for the mystics among us) – Sometimes pulling a card and journaling about what story it connects to can stir up your gut instincts in unexpected ways.
Too many ideas isn’t a curse—it’s a gift. It means your creative well is overflowing. The trick is learning to bottle that energy and pour it into one project at a time.
Your next big thing is already in your folder. You just have to choose it—and trust yourself to make it great.
Happy Writing ^_^
